Cubs and Royals reach an agreement. (REJECTED)
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
Cubs and Royals reach an agreement. (REJECTED)
Cubs Get:
C Lucas May
RP Tim Collins
SP Jake Odorizzi
Royals Get:
C Geovany Soto
RP John Grabow
C Lucas May
RP Tim Collins
SP Jake Odorizzi
Royals Get:
C Geovany Soto
RP John Grabow
G_T_G- Posts : 16
Join date : 2011-04-05
Location : IL
Re: Cubs and Royals reach an agreement. (REJECTED)
Agreed.
Just to clarify this trade, GTG won't be able to keep Soto out of the free agent draft with his current contracts. Grabow also he wont be able to retain. May has B potential and will be able to start for him right away and he can keep control of him for a while, same with Collins who would be his only lefty he will be able to retain after free agency cuts. And Odrozzi is an A potential SP prospect. Soto can come right in, I am planning on using a chize to keep him, and will start. Grabow I will be able to fit in as my lefty out of the pen until he is released this offseason and entered into the FA draft.
Just to clarify this trade, GTG won't be able to keep Soto out of the free agent draft with his current contracts. Grabow also he wont be able to retain. May has B potential and will be able to start for him right away and he can keep control of him for a while, same with Collins who would be his only lefty he will be able to retain after free agency cuts. And Odrozzi is an A potential SP prospect. Soto can come right in, I am planning on using a chize to keep him, and will start. Grabow I will be able to fit in as my lefty out of the pen until he is released this offseason and entered into the FA draft.
_MG_- Admin
- Posts : 24
Join date : 2011-04-05
Re: Cubs and Royals reach an agreement. (REJECTED)
Sorry guys but this is a very uneven trade. The Royals are giving up way to much to gain too little. Here is essentially what we are looking at:
Cubs Get:
C Lucas May #1 C, 26 yrs old, OVR C, B POT
RP Tim Collins #4 RP, 21 yrs old, OVR C, B POT
SP Jake Odorizzi #12 SP, 21 yrs old, OVR D, A POT
Royals Get:
C Geovany Soto #1 C, 28 yrs old, OVR C, B POT
RP John Grabow #4 RP, 32 yrs old, OVR C, C POT
On Paper May and Soto are quite comparable and May is entering his prime progression years while Soto will remain stagnant. The Royals would also have to use a claim on Soto to keep him on the roster. Even If May for Soto is deemed a fair trade, trading too young prospects for 1 much older average RP doesn't add up. If you guys wish for this trade to go through GTG will either have to add talent and/or MG will have to remove some.
Similar topics
» Cubs and Royals reach an agreement - AGAIN. (Approved)
» Washington Nationals and Texas Rangers Reach an agreement (Approved)
» Chicago Cubs Trade Block
» Chicago Cubs Scheduling Info.
» White Sox and Royals AGREE ON TRADE
» Washington Nationals and Texas Rangers Reach an agreement (Approved)
» Chicago Cubs Trade Block
» Chicago Cubs Scheduling Info.
» White Sox and Royals AGREE ON TRADE
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|